The Best Mixers for Spiced Rum: Classic Choices & Tasty Twists
- Dan & Katie Stratford
- Mar 24
- 5 min read
Updated: 3 days ago
Spiced rum isn't just for holidays and special occasions—it's a versatile, tasty spirit you can enjoy all year round. With warm flavours like vanilla, cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg, spiced rum offers endless mixing possibilities. Choosing the right mixer can highlight these inviting flavours and make your drink truly memorable.
Whether you're a seasoned rum enthusiast or exploring spiced rum for the first time, let's dive into some classic mixers and a few tasty twists to level up your sipping game.
Not All Spiced Rums Are Created Equal
Just like people, every spiced rum has its own personality. Some are sweeter and mellow, perfect for casual sipping or simpler mixers. Others come with richer, more intense spice profiles that demand bold pairings to match.
Knowing your rum's character helps you find the best mixers to enhance its unique taste. Let's explore some mixers that suit different styles of spiced rum.
Typical Flavour Notes of Spiced Rum
Spiced rum usually begins as a light or dark rum, then infused with various botanicals and spices. The specific spices and additives can vary significantly by brand and style, but some typical categories include:
Vanilla-Forward Rums: Smooth and sweet, often with a creamy mouthfeel. Great with cola or cream soda.
Cinnamon and Baking Spice Rums: Bold and warming, these shine with ginger beer, apple juice, or hot chocolate.
Citrus-Spiced Rums: Infused with orange peel, lemon zest, or citrus oils. Bright and zesty—pair well with lemonade or iced tea.
Tropical-Spiced Rums: Often include ingredients like allspice, coconut, or exotic fruits. Try with pineapple juice or our tropical mixer.
Common Mistakes When Mixing with Spiced Rum
Even with the best ingredients, a few simple missteps can throw off the balance of a great spiced rum drink. Here are three common mistakes to avoid:
1. Overpowering the Rum with Sweet Mixers
Spiced rum already brings a lot of flavour and sweetness to the table. Adding overly sugary mixers like some colas or fruit punches can drown out its complexity. Opt for mixers with balance—like our low-sugar Stratford Sodas—to let the rum shine.
2. Ignoring the Rum’s Flavour Profile
Not all spiced rums taste the same. Some are vanilla-forward, others lean citrusy or earthy. Mixing blindly without considering the rum’s dominant notes can result in clashing flavours. Taste first, then pair accordingly.
3. Over-Diluting with Soda Water
While a splash of soda water can lift a cocktail, too much can water down your drink and mute the spiced rum’s bold character. Be strategic—use soda to lengthen a drink without losing its punch.
Classic & Common Mixers for Spiced Rum
1. Cola - Too Sweet?
A classic Rum & Cola is sweet, bubbly, and reliably delicious. This combo is good when you want an easy-going drink that never disappoints. Cola can go well with the vanilla in a spiced rum, however, sometimes it can be too sweet and overpower the rum flavour.
2. Ginger Beer / Ginger Ale
Spiced rum and ginger beer make a dynamic duo, offering a spicy kick that complements the rum's warmth perfectly. The fire of ginger and rum is great for a warmer winter drink, but also great for the sunshine! Try it in a Spiced Rum Mule by combining combine 50ml spiced rum with 100ml ginger beer over ice, add a squeeze of lime, and garnish with a mint sprig or lime wedge —refreshing yet packed with flavour.
3. Apple Juice / Apple Cider
Apples and spice are made for each other. Pairing spiced rum with apple juice or cider highlights cinnamon and nutmeg notes, creating a cozy, autumn-inspired drink.
For a simple cocktail, combine 50ml spiced rum with 100ml cloudy apple cider in a glass over ice. Add a dash of lemon juice and a cinnamon stick for extra warmth, then garnish with a thin apple slice or star anise. Pairing spiced rum with apple juice or cider highlights cinnamon and nutmeg notes, creating a cozy, autumn-inspired drink.
4. Lemonade
A bit sweeter, lemonade balances out the spice beautifully, creating a refreshing, crowd-pleasing drink that's great for casual gatherings.
5. Pineapple Juice
For a surprising tropical twist, pineapple juice pairs wonderfully with spiced rum, adding bright sweetness and enhancing its complexity. Great for summer sipping!
6. Orange Juice
Citrusy and sweet, orange juice adds freshness and zest, making it a delicious brunch-worthy mixer with spiced rum. However sometimes the orange can conflict with flavours in some spiced rums, so tread carefully.
7. Hot Chocolate
Imagine the comforting taste of hot chocolate enhanced by warm, spicy rum. It's indulgent, rich, and good for chilly evenings— if you ever fancy a warm drink, this is one of our favourite treats.
8. Coffee (Hot or Cold Brew)
For coffee lovers, pairing spiced rum with your favourite hot or cold brew coffee creates an unexpected, sophisticated drink with deep flavours—perfect as an after-dinner cocktail. I'm still yet to try this with a "bulletproof" coffee but I think the butter and the rum would only help to improve this.
9. Club Soda / Sparkling Water - Weak and thin?
For a lighter option, club soda allows the natural flavours of spiced rum to shine through. Add a squeeze of lime for a quick, bubbly refreshment. Be careful not to dilute the rum too much, as you could end up with a thin weak drink.
The Best Spiced Rum Mixer - Stratford Sodas!
Looking to elevate your spiced rum experience? Our premium mixers are crafted specifically to
complement spiced rum's warm, inviting flavours. Made with quality ingredients, they turn everyday drinks into memorable drink moments. For spiced rums we recommend our ginger and cinnamon spiced mixer to complement the vanilla and cinnamon in spiced rums.
A wildcard mixer : Dandelion & Burdock
Dandelion and Burdock might not be your go-to mixer, but it’s a nostalgic alternative way to enjoy spiced rum. Its herbal, slightly bitter sweetness pairs intriguingly with the warm spice and vanilla of spiced rum, creating a complex, rooty drink that feels both retro and fresh.
Some of our favourite spiced rums
Choosing the right rum is crucial for creating exceptional drinks. Here are two of our absolute favourites:
Salford Spiced Rum – A small batch golden spiced rum from the old Salford Docks, this rum infuses vanilla, nutmeg, cinnamon, ginger and dried Caribbean fruits. Excellent with our spiced mixer.
Sly Dog – Winner of World's Best Spiced Rum at the World Rum Awards 2023, Sly Dog guards it's tropical spices. But the rum is great, and goes amazingly with our tropical mixer.
Explore these recommendations and discover your perfect rum-and-mixer combination.
FAQ
What’s the easiest spiced rum cocktail?
A Spiced Rum Mule – just spiced rum, ginger beer, lime juice, and ice. Simple and satisfying.
Can I mix spiced rum with fruit juice?
Yes! Pineapple, apple, and orange juice all work well—just make sure the juice complements rather than overpowers the spices.
Which mixers should I avoid with spiced rum?
Avoid overly sweet sodas or syrups that could mask the rum’s complexity. Balance is key.
What food pairings go well with spiced rum drinks?
Spiced rum pairs brilliantly with BBQ dishes, glazed meats, jerk chicken, or spiced desserts like ginger cake. For tropical-style rum drinks, grilled pineapple or coconut-based dishes are perfect.
Conclusion
Spiced rum offers incredible versatility, pairing effortlessly with mixers you likely already enjoy. The fun comes from experimenting and discovering new combinations to love.
Kommentare